The following players stood out for their performances throughout the entire 2012 season. Players are listed in order of team ranking at the end of the season. Follow the links below to see the All-Illpolo Teams:

.

2012 ALL-ILLPOLO TEAM: FIRST TEAM | SECOND TEAM | THIRD TEAM | FOURTH TEAM | FIFTH TEAM | HONORABLE MENTION

TIM NETZEL

LOYOLA

NOLAN ROBERTS
NAPERVILLE NORTH

PARKER WILKIE
LATIN

JACOB DRAY

NEW TRIER

DAVE JACKSON

BROTHER RICE

NATHAN PIMENTEL

OAK PARK

FRED JUREVICIUS

STAGG

JAIME JUAREZ
ST IGNATIUS

JJ CONNOR

GLENBROOK SOUTH

MAKAI DENEVE-ARNAM

MAINE SOUTH

JAKE ROBERTS

LWN

AUSTIN IHDE
WHEELING

JOHN BAKER
LAKE FOREST